As Blankenship plans an appeal, other miners in the U.S. and Canada fare worse
by Greg Klein
One year in prison and another on supervised release—six days apart from each other two American courts handed two former mining executives identical jail time. One ex-boss was implicated in polluting a river, the other in 29 mining deaths.
The latter, former Massey Energy CEO Don Blankenship, also got a $250,000 fine. The sentence came almost exactly six years after the underground explosion at West Virginia’s Upper Big Branch coal mine operated by a Massey subsidiary.
Widespread outrage greeted the sentence but the judge—a coal miner’s daughter—gave Blankenship the maximum penalty allowed for a misdemeanor of conspiring to violate safety regulations. In December a jury acquitted him of felony charges of securities fraud, lying to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, and conspiring to impede mine safety officials. Convictions could have brought him 31 years in prison.
In the past Blankenship reportedly donated millions to friendly politicians and judges including, Bloomberg reports, $3 million to support a West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals judge “who helped overturn a $50-million jury award against some of Massey’s units.”
John Grisham cited Blankenship as the novelist’s inspiration for The Appeal, depicting a ruthless Wall Street billionaire and his bought-and-paid-for Supreme Court judge. Grisham later wrote Gray Mountain, a fictional indictment of the Appalachian coal industry.
Alpha Natural Resources took out Massey in 2011 for $7.1 billion. Alpha eventually paid about $209 million for fines, restitution and mine safety improvements. The company also settled a securities class action suit for $265 million, as well as settling undisclosed amounts with 29 families.
Other former Upper Big Branch staff convicted after the disaster include superintendent Gary May, who got 21 months in prison, security chief Hughie Elbert Stover, who got three years, and Massey executive David Hughart, who got 42 months.
According to the United Mine Workers of America, 52 people died on Massey property under Blankenship’s reign. Still maintaining his innocence on the misdemeanor, Blankenship intends to appeal.
The week before his sentence, a federal judge in Alaska gave Canadian James Slade one year in prison and another on supervised release for criminal violations of the U.S. Clean Water Act, the Alaska Dispatch News reported.
Prosecutors described Slade as the senior on-site executive of XS Platinum during the 2010 and 2011 mining seasons when salmon-spawning streams “turned muddy brown with waste water,” according to an earlier ADN story.
The company was extracting platinum from tailings on a former mine site near the Bering Sea coast of southwestern Alaska. Slade argued that his Australian supervisors refused his request to provide equipment that would have stopped the discharge.
But the ADN quoted the judge saying Slade “really had a choice, and when it became clear the two Australians were adamant about making as much money as they could and to heck with any pollution control equipment, he could have walked away from this job.”
Two Americans face sentencing after pleading guilty to related charges. Prosecutors declined to extradite the Australians, Bruce Butcher and Mark Balfour.
The British Columbia legislature has amendments pending that could impose $1 million in fines and three years in prison for Mining Act violations. Triggered by the 2014 Mount Polley tailings dam collapse, the new regs strengthen penalties currently capped at $100,000 and one year. But following a 2015 Vancouver Sun investigation, the paper reported that “no fines had been levied in the courts under the Mines Act since 1989.”
Notwithstanding the lack of Bre-X convictions, Canada might do more to deter fraud than other mining-related offences. In 2013 the Ontario Securities Commission slapped geologist Bernard Boily with a $750,000 fine and $50,000 costs for fraudulent assays that brought a class action suit against his employer. The previous year geologist John Gregory Paterson got six years for a nearly four-year-long assay-faking scam.