Market Bottom Only in Hindsight
By John Lee
The last 18 months have been gut-wrenching for mining equity investors.
As the above chart demonstrates, the TSX Venture Composite Index, a fair representation of the junior mining sector, has come back down to levels seen in 2002, when gold first broke out of $300 an ounce.
While the TSX Venture Composite Index is still well above its 2008 low, the pain is just as pronounced now as it was then, as the TSX Composite Index, relative to the Dow, is now trading below 2009 levels. The following chart indicates a flight out of Canadian markets into the US markets.
With emerging markets, such as China, struggling and the Eurozone in outright crisis mode, global investors not only have been pouring money into US stocks but have also driven US bonds into an all-time high, ignoring the fact that the bonds are sporting negative real interest.
While this represents an extreme flight to perceived “safety,” the US dollar index has failed to break out of its 2009 high, indicating the fundamental weakness of the US dollar.
Focusing back on the gold sector, the severe correction is not just felt by the juniors but senior producers as well. Kinross, for example, is now back to its 2008 low, when gold was below $1,000 an ounce.
Overall, gold producers, relative to the price of gold, have indeed reverted back to the 2009 level as the following chart indicates.
Despite the financial crisis worldwide, gold has held up very well in the last 23 months, currently ($1,600 an ounce) trading comfortably above the 2008 crisis level ($900). This clearly shows that gold is gaining momentum as the safe haven and reserve currency in the time of crisis.
Also notice, post 2008 crisis, that gold doubled from the $800-an-ounce level to peak at more than $1,900 an ounce in less than three years. In 2008, the US Federal Reserve embarked on unprecedented quantitative easing, creating trillions of dollars to revive the banks and the equity and housing markets. Such inflationary measures had a direct positive impact on gold.
As we seemingly come out of the Euro crisis and with world governments eager to again embark on unlimited monetary easing, there are reasons to be again bullish on gold as it completes the current 18 months’ consolidation.
My conclusion is that the degree of flight to safety today and risk aversion is no less than the case in 2008. The dollar and US bonds were the main beneficiary during the 2008 crisis, and they are in the current crisis.
Post 2008 crisis, gold and gold equities were the big winner, registering triple digit gains. There are preliminary signs of gold and gold equity market bottoms, if one considers the bottoming ratios of TSX to Dow and gold equity to gold and the blowoff of US bonds.
I am reminded of two old famous adages: never catch the falling knife, and a market bottom is only known in hindsight. For me, successful investing means buying 20% from the bottom and selling 20% from the top. If we are not currently 20% from the bottom, I’d say we are darn near.
John Lee, CFA, is Chairman and Interim CEO of Prophecy Platinum Corp TSXV:NKL and Chairman and CEO of Prophecy Coal Corp TSX:PCY. He holds degrees in economics and engineering from Rice University in Houston, Texas. The views expressed above are those of the author and may not reflect those of Prophecy Platinum Corp or Prophecy Coal Corp. Read here for a feature story on Prophecy Platinum and its Wellgreen copper-nickel-PGE project. Prophecy Platinum is a client of OnPage Media.